Sunday, August 20, 2023

A Recap of Holmes in the Heartland 2023

Holmes in the Heartland: Arch Enemies was a huge success!  More than 90 Sherlockians from the St. Louis area and around the country spent three days celebrating Sherlock Holmes and mingling with one another.  

The weekend officially kicked off on Friday afternoon, but plenty of folks arrived on Thursday and connected with one another.  Some went out to dinner, others hung out at the hotel, and one group braved the heat to attend a Cardinals game.





Friday

Friday afternoon found the Sheraton Westport hopping as everyone started arriving.  Brad Keefauver captured the energy of seeing everyone with this blog post.

Our first official event was an architectural tour of the St. Louis Public Library, followed by a viewing of the St. Louis Sherlock Holmes Research Collection in the library's Rare Books and Manuscript Room.  The Central Branch of the St. Louis Library is a gorgeous place, and the tours highlighted some amazing aspects of the place.  And people really seemed to enjoy looking over books from the collection and discussing certain aspects of specific pieces spread throughout the room.






There were a few hours for everyone to grab a bite to eat with friends after the library before our next event, the Just Desserts for Professor Moriarty banquet, sponsored by The John H. Watson Society.  Everyone enjoyed treats and coffee in a relaxed atmosphere while door prizes were raffled off to attendees.








Saturday

The biggest day of the weekend was Saturday.  The doors opened at 8:30 and the vendors started doing a brisk business right away.  While they eyed up purchases, attendees also mingled with one another and viewed the day's door prizes.



The speaker line up was a blast!  If we tried to recap every wonderful thing that was said, this blog post would be as long as an encyclopedia.  So we will just share the line up along with some pictures here.


Ray Betzner - Professor James Moriarty, and the Quest for Order in the Universe



Kristen Mertz - Moran's Game



Cindy Brown - Guys I Love to Hate: The List Keeps Getting Longer



Steven Doyle - Baron Gruner: The Most Misunderstood Villain in the Canon



Mike McSwiggin - The Ultimate Arch Enemies of the Canon: Dr. Watson and Calendars


Beth Gallego - Enemies for Life: Faces of Moriarty in Sherlockian Literature for Youth


Monica Schmidt - BBC, But You Do Not Observe: Sociopathy and Sherlock Holmes


Joe Eckrich, Rich Krisciunas, & Michael Waxenberg - Jefferson Hope: The Trial of the (19th) Century


As intriguing as these titles and pictures are, they don't even begin to do justice to the fantastic presentations.  We were very lucky to have such a great line up of speakers this year!

After a short break and time for socialization in the hotel bar, we were treated to a great buffet dinner.  Two of our local members, Adam Presswood and Stacey Bregenzer, gave toasts to Arthur Conan Doyle and villains in the Canon.  These toasts will be published in full in our next blog post.



After everyone was fully fed and we went through the dessert table more than a few times, it was time for the night's entertainment: The Alpha Inn Goose Club Trivia Night.  Brad Keefauver and his trusty goose companion, Steve Mason, took the group through trivia that spanned decades, genres, and myriads of interests.




Sunday

People who opted for the three-day registration got to visit the St. Louis Arch that included a guided tour of the new history museum, a trip to the top of the Arch, a documentary film on the building of the Arch, and of course some souvenir shopping.  We wrapped up the weekend with lunch at The Old Spaghetti Factory on Laclede's Landing before everyone finally filtered out on their ways back home.












Thursday, July 20, 2023

A Look Back at The Parallel Case of St. Louis by Joe Eckrich


With the second “Holmes in the Heartland” conference almost upon us, I thought it would be appropriate to take a look back the history of The Parallel Case of St. Louis and our previous St. Louis conferences.  

We began, rather inauspiciously, on 15 November 1998, a small group of Sherlockians meeting in my apartment in Shrewsbury, Missouri, a suburb of St. Louis.  However, the idea for the group began during meetings of The Noble Bachelors, the oldest scion society in St. Louis.  They met two or three times a year, usually in dinner meetings with 30 – 40 people attending.  There was always a Sherlockian program but little or no opportunity to discuss the actual stories.  So sprang the idea of a smaller group meeting more often to discuss the Canon and anything else of Sherlockian note.  The idea took off and 35 years later we are still meeting and still discussing one case at a time.

For a name I wanted something with a connection to St. Louis.  There were actually two mentions of St. Louis in the Canon; “the Jefferson Hopes of St. Louis” in a STUDY IN SCARLET and, in THE SIGN OF FOUR, Holmes talks of referring a French detective, Francois le Villard, to two parallel cases involving a will which took place in Riga in 1857 and in St. Louis in 1871.  “The Jefferson Hopes” was already taken, so I chose “The Parallel Case of St. Louis.”  Note that case is singular, although our first booklet was titled “The Parallel Cases of St. Louis”.  More on that later.

We began meeting in members’ homes and eventually moved to a mystery bookstore called “The Big Sleep."  Helen Simpson, owner of The Big Sleep, kindly opened up just for us on the evening of our meeting, on the third Monday of every other month at first, and eventually the 3rd Thursday of every  other month.  During the first year we began the practice of inviting guest speakers periodically beginning with John Lutz, a local author of mystery and suspense books.  We also had Francis M. Nevins, author and Ellery Queen expert, Fred Levin, BSI, a noted Chicago Sherlockian quite knowledgeable about the Reichenbach Falls, and Bob Randisi, mystery author and president of the Private Eyes of America.

In 1989 we held our first Summer banquet with guest speaker Tony Harries who had been secretary to Sherlock Holmes at the Abby National in London.  The following year our guest speaker was David Hammer, BSI, Sherlockian author and publisher.  

In 1991 Pat Accardo suggested we should have a newsletter and offered to edit it with me as co-editor.  It was named “The Parallelogram” and ran for over 10 years.  In 1999 we produced our first “writings on the writings," a booklet entitled “The Parallel Cases of St. Louis."  We produced a second booklet, “Romancing The Hound” on August 2001 for both the 10th anniversary of "The Parallelogram” and the 100th anniversary of the publishing of the first part of THE HOUND OF THE BASKERVILLES in the Strand Magazine.  While a totally separate booklet, it was listed as Special Supplement Number One of “The Parallelogram” and sold separately.


St. Louis has a proud history of Sherlockian Conferences beginning in the 1990s.  The Harpooners of the Sea Unicorn produced several in St. Charles, Missouri, including “The Game’s Afloat” in 1998 which took place on a Showboat docked in St. Charles.  The speakers for this event were Terence Faherty, Brad Keefauver, Rosemary Michaud, Roy Pilot and John Smithkey III.  These were followed by two at Westport Plaza, the location of this year’s Holmes in the Heartland, at the old Westport Playhouse.  These were joint efforts with all of the St. Louis scion societies. 

The Parallel Case of St. Louis then held two conferences under the banner “Holmes Under the Arch” and “Holmes Under the Arch II”.  The first took place in 1999 and was subtitled “Weekend at Baskerville Hall” and included a murder mystery written by Brad Keefauver to be solved during the weekend.  Both conferences were highly successful but for limitation of space I will concentrate on the second.  This was held at the Holiday Inn/Viking hotel and conference center in Sunset Hills, a St. Louis suburb.  It took place on June 20 – 22, 2005 and was very well attended.  Our speakers included Catherine Cooke, current Chairperson of The Sherlock Holmes Society of London and, at the time, librarian at The Marylebone Library in charge of their Sherlock Holmes collection.  She spoke on “1951 – A Vintage Year”, about the Festival of Britain and Marylebone’s contribution of Sherlock Holmes study and the resulting founding of The Sherlock Holmes Society of London.  Les Klinger spoke on “Game Over."  Les had produced THE NEW ANNOTATED SHERLOCK HOLMES, which played “the game” of Holmes and Watson being real people, which we know they are.  As such he and the Annotated received some criticism from various sources, which was his subject.

Bill Mason, with the able assistance of his wife Cynthia Mason, gave us “Hooray For Doctor Sterndale, The African Explorer."  Among other things, Bill posited that Dr. Sterndale was the inspiration for “one of the greatest and most memorable classic scenes in the history of cinema.  I speak, of course,  of the 1930 film, “Animal Crackers," and more specifically, to the movies signature musical number, “Hooray for Captain Spaulding”.  Bill and Cindy then proceeded to give us various stanzas of the song substituting Dr. Sterndale for Dr. Spaulding with a riotous conclusion.  Julie McKuras then gave us “Holmes on the Mississippi” and spoke about our own Gray Chandler Briggs and also the beginnings of the Sherlockian collection at the University of Minnesota.  This was followed by Sue Vizoskie’s “Downstairs in the Canon” and particularly Mrs. Isabella Beeton and her BOOK OF HOUSEHOLD MANAGEMENT.  In addition, we held a pastiche writing contest with the winning pastiche “The Adventure of the Empty Case of The King of Beers” by Julie and Mike McKuras.


The First “Holmes in the Heartland” took place in 2018.  We were due to follow it up two years later but something called Covid interfered and then there were a few other conference scheduled elsewhere, so here we are in 2023 ready for our second “Holmes in the Heartland."

As you can see St. Louis is a place to be reckoned with when we discuss Sherlockian Conferences!


Monday, June 5, 2023

Holmes in the Heartland 2023

You may have seen and heard about Holmes in the Heartland, but have you really observed what all is happening in St. Louis on July 28-30?  We are packed to the gills with a weekend full of Sherlockian events, speakers, vendors, sites, and surprises.  This is a weekend you won't want to miss!


The weekend kicks off on Friday afternoon with an architectural tour of the gorgeous central branch of the St. Louis Public Library.  Upon completion, we will adjourn to the city's Rare Books and Manuscript Room for a viewing of the St. Louis Sherlock Holmes Research Collection.  

After the library closes at 5, everyone will move back to Westport Plaza.  All around our hotel are great choices for dinner with Sherlockian friends, both new and old.  And we haven't forgotten about the late-night socialization that happens at these events.  You can count on a great time after dinner if you want to keep the party going!

The doors will open Saturday morning for those of us who like to get to the vendors tables first.  And you'll want plenty of time to peruse our packed shopping options!  Make sure to leave space in your luggage for books from Wessex Press, Books on the Square, and BSI Press along with Sherlockian treasures from Lynda Conway, Joe Eckrich, Regina Stinson, Mike McSwiggin, Steve Mason, and The Practical Preservers of Sherlock Holmes.


Then you're in for a full day of Arch Enemies with presentations by Ray Betzner, Kristen Mertz, Cindy Brown, Steven Doyle, Mike McSwiggin, Beth Gallego, Monica Schmidt, and the St. Louis Costumers Guild.  Enjoy topics covering Professor Moriarty, Colonel Moran, Baron Gruner, psychology, and Watson's arch nemesis.  And because Sherlockian events are known for their food and socializing, we've built plenty of time into Saturday's schedule for lunch and socialization breaks in between all of these fascinating speakers.

But Saturday isn't finished after all of these speakers.  The festivities will continue with a Sherlockian dinner banquet that evening with canonical toasts and a rousing round of Alpha Inn Goose Club Trivia, hosted by your trivia landlord, Brad Keefauver, and his sidekick, a Texas-size goosed who bears an uncanny resemblance to Steve Mason.  If you still have energy left after all of this fun, plan on joining fellow Sherlockians for nightlife on more time!


And how could we theme this weekend "Arch Enemies" and not take our guests to the Gateway Arch?  Sunday morning will find scores of Sherlockians visiting the Gateway to the West for a trip to the top of the Arch, guided tour of its history museum, and film on the building of this landmark.  We'll squeeze in one more meal at a riverfront eatery, and then it will be time for us all to head back to the real world, but full of all of the memories we've made over the past few days!

Registration is open now and hotel rooms are going fast!  Two- and three-day packages are available for your travel arrangements.  And if you are new to Sherlockiana or St. Louis, don't let that deter you.  We will send out driving and parking information out ahead of time.  Sherlockians are unbelievably welcoming and once you get here, you won't be a stranger very long!

If you have any questions, please reach out to us  and we will be happy to answer any questions.  We look forward to meeting you in St. Louis!



Tuesday, May 30, 2023

221con 2023: It was the Bees Knees!! by Kristin Mertz

This year was 221B Con’s 10-year anniversary.  How on earth can 10 years have passed already and where is our 6th Season of Benedict Cumberbatch as our venerable detective?  Have no fear Cumberbunnies, he is still out there playing wonderful characters, just not as good as Sherlock, but I digress.  As always, arrival on Thursday evening is the best choice so you can sit in restaurant/bar area to greet all your friends from past cons as they filter in, catch up with said friends, make new friends, and, if you’re lucky, listen to the witty banter of Curtis Armstrong and Ashley Polasek.  Bonus, this year Paul Thomas Miller even crossed the pond to be with us, what a treat!  I bet you wish you had come, but have no fear you can live vicariously right here, provided you can make sense of my silliness.  Off we pop then!

Friday morning is a free day waiting to check in.  Lucky me got to go to Waffle House for breakfast with Baron von Bork and crew (that would be Paul, Brad, Madeline, Heather, was Shana there? I feel like I’m missing someone!)  Not just ANY Waffle House, we have standards!  Only those recommended by Steve Mason, Waffle House connoisseur.  I have my Waffle House Investiture to prove it (not the BSI investiture, I am working on that one, or planning for that one, or hoping for that one…insert shameless plug here…I wouldn’t say no!). 

Blah, blah, blah, some stuff happened, and then we were ready to check in and get that coveted program (ooo, look at that pretty art by Sebastian Broome).  As usual, the amount of panels to choose from was exceptional, from standard canon topics, to fan fiction, world building and writing, random fandom discussions (not random…I just liked the rhyme there) from Good Omens (All Hail Gaiman!) to Star Wars, and all the detective talk you could ever want, including some good old Enola Holmes.

Friday night I chose to attend “The Crimes of Sherlock Holmes”, a discussion led by an actual lawyer (who knew we had so many lawyers *wink, wink*).  We got to vote as a jury on his guilt for various and sundry crimes.  Some people wanted him hanged at every turn, whereas others of us (possibly me) would have been disqualified as jurors as we could see nothing criminal in any of Holmes’ activities (e.g. they had to break in, they heard a baby crying).  Overall, quite the lively discourse, but I think the prosecutor was slightly disappointed in the majority of us. 

Another absolute requirement on the Friday evening docket was the screening of Sherlock Holmes & Dinosaurs, what is the ACTUAL name of the movie?  Hmmm….not important.  The important thing is that it is on the Doyle’s Rotary Coffin movie list for very good reasons, so many reasons….dinosaurs.  No spoilers here, all I can say is make sure your disbelief is well suspended before watching, as if “Sherlock and Dinosaurs” did not imply this.

To wrap up the first night….karaoke!!!  Yes, I sang. Yes, Brad sang and before US there were some very impressive singers.  One small piece of advice, BEFORE you sign up for karaoke make sure you bring some extra alcohol to keep your nerve up OR pick a song that everyone will sing with you. I did neither or those things (audible sigh, lesson probably not learned).

Saturday, I actually got up early enough to make that secret meeting in the secret room (some of you know what I mean, *more winks*).  Then attended the “221B Con Turns Ten” panel where we learned some fun facts about the Con’s origins and the group’s ability to clear out the bar year after year.  On a very sad note, “Covered in Bees” was cancelled because the hotel's bees died. I think it was the few freezes that hit Atlanta if I remember correctly.  Very sad for all of us bee supporters.  I truly hope they can establish another colony.  If the bees didn’t have you crying, the montage at the end definitely did.

On to the Scarlet Threat of Venery led by Marilynne McKay.  If you are unfamiliar with what this topic entails, google it with caution. I personally was very glad I ate earlier, but overall a very enlightening panel on the medicine, or lack thereof, in Victorian times.  “The Worst Sherlock” was next.  Ironically or probably wisely, the panel leaders opted not to show for and frankly, I had to leave as I have clearly chosen Will Ferrell as the worst and I will not entertain any other option. If you disagree, fight me.  I choose one stick. 

The annual Costume Exhibition was as usual a really good time with some great cosplays.  Picture included for you to figure out all those references. 

Dracula Daily panel was another great discussion.  Of course I signed up for the daily emails, because what Sherlockian doesn’t like a good chronology?  And who doesn’t love vampires?  Except for that one from Sussex.  I mean, what kind of vampire lives in the SUNNY part of England?  Probably that sparkly kind *shudder*.

Somewhere, in the middle of all that, I ate at the #fudtruck and made it to the vendor’s room.  Somehow I managed to not spend a fortune, despite all the fan art, books, costumes, journals….so many pretty, pretty things.  I got a few books (thank you Brad Keefauver and Paul Thomas Miller, I can’t wait to read them!), a fairy tale tarot set with some amazing Japanese art because no one can have too many tarot sets, right?  And, one of my favorites, the “Major Holmes and Captain Watson” graphic novel (https://cloudwranglerstore.com/collections/major-holmes-captain-watson ).  I think, nay, I know I chose well.

And then, for some reason, I thought Ballroom Dancing, I will be good at that.  I might have had a drink or two before this thought occurred to me, possibly more, who’s counting at this point anyway? Unfortunately for me, counting was involved, one step forward, one step to the side, wait, forward is leading right?  Do I go to the right or to the left? As you can see the lessons didn’t take. Thank goodness I had a pretty good partner who could lead because I can only follow…in dancing, who knew?  Those of you who know me will see the irony in this. I think by the end I was doing some kind of line dance, at least I tried.

This led to being tired of dancing by the time the dance party rolled around. This worked out great because all the cool kids were in Mrs. Hudson’s room, not dancing.  And when you tell someone the bar is closed and they say, “That’s OK, I have a bottle of Johnny Walker Black.  Would you like some?”  The only answer is, “Yes! Please!”  We may have done a podcast for the John H Watson Society, I’m not really sure how much I helped.  Listen for yourself, it is on the web.  Fun was had by all and no Sherlockians were harmed in the taking of these pictures!


Sunday morning came and I did not manage to get out of bed until, let’s just say late, therefore, missing all the early panels. I don’t know what happened (*Mrs. Hudson’s room shenanigans may have gone late, alcohol was definitely involved, we were definitely NOT clueing for looks so I guess we will never know*).  I recovered in time to attend the “Adventuresses of Sherlock Holmes, Baker Street Irregulars and other Sherlockian Societies” panel, which gave a little history of those fine societies.  We also had a guest from the Atlanta Scion, The Wisteria Lodge, wearing a lovely Victorian costume. If you are interested in learning more on the group, here is their Facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/groups/AtlantaSherlockHolmesSociety/.

My last panel was the highly anticipated “Brown Studies with Ashely & Curtis: The Worst Adventures of Sherlock Holmes” in kilts, because who doesn’t take an opportunity to wear a kilt.  They quite fine together.  An entertaining discussion of the casebook ensued and why it is underrated or bad? I took no notes and vaguely remember the fine details. I do remember I was thoroughly entertained. I could listen to Ashley and Curtis talk for hours about whatever and never get tired of it. I hope they do this every year. If they do and I write another blog post, I promise I will catch some witty quotes, I promise…really.


Sadly, it came time for “Our Last Bow” where the organizers wrap up the year, take comments and say goodbye until next year.  Congratulations to the Crystal, Heather and all the lovely people who helped to organize this event on 10 years of giving us the most quirky, jam packed full weekends of Sherlock fandom fun there can be in Atlanta, including all the floor bacon you can handle, begging the question, is there ever enough floor bacon?  This is where I will leave you as well, with the hope that I will see you there in 2024.  I’m already signed up and if all of the above sounded like the blast it was you should too!  Go, do it now, we will be waiting (see Brad’s look of disbelief that you haven’t signed up yet).

Thursday, April 27, 2023

A Question of Timing by Adam Presswood


I guess no Sherlock Holmes fan is ever too old to learn something new. In advance of the May 2023 meeting of The Parallel Case of St. Louis, I have just finished reading “The Adventure of the Mazarin Stone” for probably only the second or third time in my life. For whatever reason, this particular story has never really been on my Sherlockian radar. So as not to usurp the lively discussion that I hope will occur at our meeting, I will refrain from any restatement of the plot. Instead, I will mention the two looming factors that I am sure all of you are already more than familiar with. The first is that the story is one of only two Holmes adventures written in third person, the second being “His Last Bow.” The other factor is that the entire story takes place in one small corner of Holmes’s rooms at 221B Baker Street.


I found myself curious as to why, and this is when I realized that I have not amassed nearly as much Sherlockian trivia as I sometimes like to think. As it turns out, “The Adventure of the Mazarin Stone” was adapted from a stage play, hence the one-room setting. The play, titled The Crown Diamond, was first performed in May of 1921, and "The Adventure of the Mazarin Stone" was published in October of that same year. There is general agreement that both the play and the short story are set in the summer of 1903. That, however, is where most of the agreement stops, as opinions differ wildly as to whether the play was written just a few months before the story was published, or whether there was instead a gap of many years between the two works. This argument is further complicated by the fact that, in the play, the villain is Colonel Sebastian Moran, the deadly big game hunter who falls into Holmes’s trap in “The Adventure of the Empty House," rather than Count Negretto Sylvius, Sherlock’s adversary in “The Adventure of the Mazarin Stone.”


For me, the temptation to dive into the timeline here was simply irresistible. “The Adventure of the Empty House" is one of 13 stories in The Return of Sherlock Holmes. The story was published in both England and America in 1903, but the adventure detailed therein is set nine years earlier, in 1894. As every Sherlockian knows, Moran is bested by Holmes in that story, unwittingly playing the part of the tiger lured to his doom, rather than the role of hunter that he thinks he is playing. He is then led off by Lestrade and his men and his fate is in the hands of the court. Holmes seems relatively confident that the second most dangerous man in London will trouble the world no more. Whatever the court may have decided in terms of Moran’s sentence, he was not put to death, as Holmes refers to him as still among the living in “The Adventure of the Illustrious Client." That means Moran was still above ground in September of 1902, even though he was probably not a free man. While pondering his enemy list at the end of his career, Holmes once again refers to Moran in “His Last Bow," and once again Moran is still alive, at least according to Holmes. That places Moran on our side of the grass as late as 1914 or so, even though “His Last Bow” was not published until three years later.


If we take the long view, we can assume that Doyle was telling his readers that Moran remained alive until at least 1917, just four short years before The Crown Diamond was first performed in 1921. That year would have marked the 27th anniversary of Moran’s arrest in “The Adventure of the Empty House." If we accept the rather lengthy biography that Doyle provides for Moran, he was born in 1840. That means he was already 54 years old when he attempted to murder Holmes, and he would have been 81 when the play was released in 1921. In fairness, he would only have been 63 in 1903, the year in which both the play and the short story are set. Still, two factors must be considered here. The first is that our villain wasn’t getting any younger. That second is that, even if we arrest the aging process for the infamous Moran, his scant mention in the years since 1894 would have made him an unlikely choice for the antagonist in a play written as late as 1921.


All of this is, of course, only my perspective. However, I feel that the timeline works very strongly against the notion of the play and the short story being written within months of one another, given that Moran was the villain in the stage version. I think it far more likely that the play was written shortly after “The Adventure of the Empty House," when Moran’s character would have been far fresher in the minds of Doyle’s readers. There are still a few hiccups in my theory, the primary one being that the play is still set nine years after Moran’s arrest in the empty house across from 221B Baker Street. But after all, it is the stage we are talking about here, so we must allow for some poetic license where the canonical timeline is concerned. So I leave it to all of you. Are we dealing with a renamed, 63-year-old Moran in “The Adventure of the Mazarin Stone," or are the two works thought to be mere months apart simply because of the proximity in their respective release dates? You have until May 13th to make up your minds😊