Saturday, October 22, 2022

October News and Announcements


It was a triumphant return to Zoom this month for The Parallel Case of St. Louis!  Nobody was sick, we just missed our out-of-town friends.  And our friends came out to play!  Almost 50 folks attended the meeting last weekend and it was great to see everyone.  We are experimenting with an alternating schedule of Zoom and in-person meetings right now.  More details on this schedule below.


Holmes in the Heratland is getting closer and closer!  Many of our out-of-town friends got to see the new Holmes in the Heartland website for the first time last weekend and excitement is growing!  If you haven't reserved your spot for next July's conference here in St. Louis, you can do so on the website now.

A new book edited by Rob Nunn and Brad Keefauver, The Monstrum Opus of Sherlock Holmes, is now available.  This book is a new collection of 17 essays arguing that some of Holmes's most famous cases were actually cover ups for something much more monstrous.  Our own Heather Hinson appears in this collection as well, connecting the ancient lore behind Ghostbusters to a familiar family in the Canon...


Enola Holmes 2 will be released next month on Netflix and new trailers seem to be coming out every week.  This will be sure to get some folks talking about Holmes!

Our November meeting will be in-person to discuss "The Dying Detective" on November 12.  You can RSVP on the Facebook event page.

We will return to Zoom in December to talk about "The Devil's Foot."  Information for that Zoom meeting will come out in November.

Thursday, October 20, 2022

Bruce-Partington Sub-Conscious Musings

Another offering in the alternative-reality game of "where did ACD get the idea to write that fictional story?" This entry in that game: Bruce-Partington Plans (BRUC). 



Set up the Game:

Where did ACD get the ideas for the plot of Bruce-Partington Plans?

BRUC was first published in 1908 in the Strand Magazine. Previously, The Adventure of the Naval Treaty had been published in October, 1893, which like BRUC, also involved espionage and theft of secret papers from the Royal Navy.



The Game proceeds:

Notably for purposes of this game, ACD had killed off Sherlock Holmes in The Final Problem published in December 1893. Holmes' death left the newly created fans of Holmes bereft, and also deprived the Strand of a popular selling point. Other authors at that time took the opportunity try to fill the gap by offering detective stories in the fashion of Sherlock Holmes. In 1894, Strand published a series of stories by Arthur Morrison about a private detective named Martin Hewitt. The August 1894 issue had the story "The Dixon Torpedo" about the theft of secret plans for a naval torpedo, an underwater naval weapon, from a locked room, and the consequent danger to the Royal Navy if those plans fell into the wrong hands. Morrison's story even includes a drawing of the rooms where the theft occurred, just as Naval Treaty had a drawing of the scene in that story.

After the Parallel Case meeting on Oct. 15, 2022, I obtained a copy of "The Dixon Torpedo" and read it. It is available for free at Project Gutenberg:



"Dixon Torpedo" is a short and fun story. But Morrison's story does not measure up to all the good qualities of ACD's writing, such as pacing, drama, colorful descriptions, and character study. But to be fair, it has a decent plot involving espionage, a locked room mystery, and a private detective who is willing to do a bit of burglary for a good cause. And it has missing secret naval plans, combining detective mystery with a spy thriller.

Thus, while Holmes was temporarily dead (in a literary sense), Morrison gave us private detective Martin Hewitt and a mystery plot that fired up feelings of British patriotism while filling the hole left by Holmes's absence for detective stories in the pages of Strand Magazine. Then, Holmes was raised from the dead in 1903, and BRUC followed in 1908.

To Conclude this Game:

ACD probably borrowed plot ideas from Arthur Morrison's story "The Dixon Torpedo" (1893) when he wrote BRUC (1908). The story about the theft of plans for an underwater submarine is too similar to theft of plans for an underwater torpedo to be mere coincidence.

Morrison certainly copied ACD's use of a clever private detective as the protagonist, and was likely influenced by Naval Treaty (1893) when he wrote "Dixon Torpedo" in 1894.

In short, first Morrison copied Doyle, and then Doyle copied Morrison, returning the compliment of copying another author's ideas. 


Game over.
Until the next installment. 

We now return to objective reality, where Holmes is real, and Martin Hewitt is merely a fictional character created by English author Arthur George Morrison (1863 to 1945). Holmes may have his literary knock-offs and rivals, but no real life rival since the demise of Prof. Moriarty.

Monday, September 19, 2022

September News and Announcements



September News and Announcements

First things first: have you registered for Holmes in the Heartland yet?  If not, check out the website and get signed up!

And we will be holding one of our semi-regular Zoom meetings next month to discuss "The Adventure of the Bruce-Partington Plans."  You can pre-register for the meeting here.

The Occupants of the Empty House hosted their final meeting on September 17.  Brad Keefauver has a nice writeup on that meeting on his blog.

Enola Holmes 2 will be coming to Netflix in November.

The Harpooners of the Sea Unicorn will meet via Zoom on September 23.

The Baker Street Almanac has been delivered to subscribers and is highly recommended.  If you didn't preorder one, they are still available here.

Joe will be the keynote speaker at December's Crew of the Barque Lone Star Zoom meeting.

Josh Harvey created a great video for our Scion on his YouTube page.

And Nellie had some great pictures from the time she visited Hotel National.  Check them out below!





Tuesday, August 16, 2022

July News and Announcements

Opening up, there was a brief discussion- run down of this year's 221B Con.  Next year will be held April 14-16 2023.  

Holmes, Doyle & Friends will happen in Dayton again next year March 24-25, 2023. 

 And then Holmes in the Heartland is happening July 28-30, 2023. Registration will be open later this summer.  

The Sherlock Holmes in 221 objects will be in Bloomington Indiana August 6th and there will be speakers at this event.  Registration is open now. 

 Also, the Toronto Jubilee 221B the 50th anniversary of the collection at the Toronto Library as well as the 50th anniversary of the Bootmakers of Toronto.  Sept 23-25, registration now open.  Included on the 22nd of September is the ACD Toronto walk.  Keynote speakers are Nicholas Meyer and Douglas Kerr.

The Audible podcast Moriarty: The Devils' Game was brought up as a listening suggestion by Nellie as was the Spotify original podcast Scotland Yard Confidential. The narrator's name is John Hopkins which (hypothetically) could have a tie in with Sherlock Holmes.


Discussion about the Red Circle: 

The original title was supposed to be The Adventure of the Bloomsbury Lodger

The book opens with Mrs. Warren worrying about a lodger who paid double rent and stays in their room.  The question was asked, why is any landlady worrying about a tenant who pays double and is quiet?

Bob suggested that Klinger mentioned the landlady was actually in charge of a rooming house which was a lower class of lodging than boarding houses like the ones Holmes and Watson lived in.

Originally Holmes is not interested in the case- Scrapbooking was more important. 

While Holmes digs through the Daily Gazette, he doesn't grow interested until Mr Warren is kidnapped.  

Ora asked how did the group find the lodger and why did they kidnap the wrong person.  It was a foggy morning. 

Nellie added that they threw the coat behind the victim and maybe that's how they didn't know who they caught. 

Wayne asked just how many male lodgers did the home have?

Nellie's favorite part of the story was the Agony column of the Daily Gazette and how Holmes just loudly reads parts and makes commentary. 

Question: why were the associates of Black Gorgiano not worried about after the man was killed?  

Wayne suggested that because it wasn't really Red Circle business that one Gorgiano was murdered, the others just dispersed. 

Mary read a paper she wrote for this story titled Reader Beware: The Red Circle.  She talks about several things from the story including the easy coded messages and  where are all the WC's and if Mrs. Warren was cataloguing everything the mysterious border asked for then why isn't fresh water for hand washing or chamber pots mentioned?

This turned into a discussion about London being behind in basic things like sanitation, heating and cooling and pipes.  Kristen talked about the retrofitting of the lamps to electric. 

This brought up that Mary also read a paper she wrote on  The Adventure of the Gloria Scott at a Parallel Cases meeting in 2005 also discussing coded messages. 

Joe mentioned the Long Island Cave mystery mentioned by the Pinkerton agent. There are no caves in Long Island. 

Bob mentioned that Klinger spoke about the Red Circle maybe being part of the Freemasons and the Italian mafia and brought up Lodge 21- and Godfather 3.  Conan Doyle had a on and off thing with secret societies  as he was an on and off member of the Masons. 

The consensus of how the group liked the story was mixed.  It was more of a meh.  The story was in The Last Bow which was published in 1911.

Also a quick debate if there were any similarities between Gorgiano and Moriarty outside  having a one on one confrontation and losing and working with an organization. Gorgiano's mission was personal where Moriarty's mission was business. Other than that, no real correlation. 


The next meeting is on September 10 @ 1pm  at the Ethical Society and will be covering "The Disappearance of Lady Frances Carfax."


Wednesday, June 22, 2022

The Adventure of the Queen's Jubilee by Kristen Mertz

It is June. A glorious summer day, but Sherlock is bored, very, VERY bored.  What should Watson do when Sherlock is in such a state and of all days for this to be the situation, the very day of Queen Victoria’s Golden Jubilee. He must try to occupy Sherlock’s mind of course, but how?

I remember the events clearly. The day was June the 20th of 1897.  No murders to speak of.  No odd visitors with curious problems to solve.  In other words, a very tedious day to be one Mr. Sherlock Holmes.  He is in one of his melancholic moods, re-reading through the latest news searching for anything of interest, apparently to no avail as he has been sighing loudly and tossing each sheet into an ever-growing pile at his feet. Mrs. Hudson has more than once entered the room, attempting without success, to offer food or tea. The last attempt was met with Holmes waving her off. She just shook her head, tsk’d and mumbled under her breath, “Well, I guess there’s nothin’ for it then” as she closed the door behind herself.

I have been asking myself all morning how to get Holmes out of his ever-blackening mood.  “I say Holmes, all the papers only have news of the Jubilee. I fear there’s nothing to be done for it.  Why don’t we go for a stroll and see for ourselves?”  That only earned me a scathing look and a haughty retort.  “Are you out of your mind Watson? There is a man giving out tobacco and alcohol on the streets.  Every dull-witted simpleton will be out and about today. I am in not any mood to deal with those wretched fools today.  Really, what can you be thinking.” Holmes opened the last paper, glancing at it quickly before standing up quickly and throwing it to the ground. “Confound this day!”, he yelled and stalked off toward the kitchen.

What a shame, I thought to myself. It is a lovely day after all. How wonderful it would be to take a stroll and enjoy the weather. Of course, I couldn’t expect Holmes to tolerate the chaos caused by the Jubilee, unless of course there was a murder scene at the end of it. I must think of something and quickly, before he decided to decorate another wall in buckshot to alleviate his foul mood.

I dropped into my chair, wracking my brain trying to think of something, anything to do with this woe begotten day.  It is too late for a trip to the country.  Bah, even if I had suggested it earlier, we have just recently returned from the Cornish peninsula from that rest suggested by the doctor. For all the good that did him.  Holmes had managed to find another case and whatever rest and relaxation he did eventually get has apparently been too much for him if his current state is any indication.


A visit to Mycroft?  Hardly something to put Holmes in a good mood; and, I would have to deal with Mycroft as well.  Violin?  No, no, he would recognize that as a feeble attempt it is to lighten his mood.  Cold cases?  Perhaps digging through some of Holmes’ old cases to find something to discuss? No, Holmes would just think I was writing about whatever it was, that surely won’t work. Perhaps an unsolved case?  Jack the Ripper?  No, that was a sore point with Holmes as the Yard never requested his assistance, despite their very obvious need at the time.  And now, with the murders stopped and the trail grown so cold over the years, that would surely do nothing but worsen the situation. Lunch perhaps at the …oh what am I thinking, even if we could find a hansom, the streets are crowded and I’m sure the eateries are over-filled.   

Holmes strode back in the room and threw himself into his chair, breaking me out of my reverie.  Without thinking I leapt to my feet and blurted out, “I challenge you to a single stick match!” No sooner had the words left my mouth, did I immediately regret them. Sherlock’s mouth dropped open for only a second before he pursed his lips and said, “Good god man, what has gotten into to you today.  You cannot be serious.”  “I am utterly serious, I assure you,” I stuttered. “Very well, if you insist,” said Holmes and promptly turned on his heel.

Holmes is right, I thought to myself, what has gotten into me.  I have very little idea how to handle a single stick.  Only from watching Holmes did I even know how to hold one properly.

Holmes walked back into the room holding 2 sticks and tossed one to me.  I am not at all sure how, but I caught it.  He threw off his robe and tossed it on the chair and kicked off his house slippers. He stepped his right foot forward and lifted the stick over his right shoulder with his left arm down at his side. I awkwardly imitated his stand and said shakily, “En guard.”  Why did I say that?  I inwardly cursed at myself.

Holmes chuckled, nodding his head at me slightly.  In the blink of an eye, he twirled the stick in an X, striking both sides of my front leg and before I could take another breath, twirled the stick in another X, tapping both sides of my collarbone, ending with a quick tap to the left side of my head.  “I’m afraid you have lost quite badly dear chap. You didn’t even get a hit.”  Holmes shook his head and laughed.  “I really do not know what you are about today Watson.”

“Holmes!  You didn’t even give me a chance to…I …I never…” I huffed, dropped the stick to the floor and threw myself back into my chair.  “I was simply trying to get you out of that dark mood you’ve been in all day!” I was beside myself.


Holmes barked out another laugh at my expense. “Good lord man…challenging me to single stick.  You must have been absolutely desperate!  Are you quite finished now?  I don’t think I can take any more of your cheering.”

I held my hands up.  “I surrender, you have put me at my wits end old fellow.”  I dropped my hands into my lap, threw my head back and muttered, ”Damn the Jubilee.”

“Is that what this is about?”, queried Holmes, shaking his head.  “You could have just…” Holmes stopped mid-sentence, tilting his head slightly.  He snatched his robe from the chair, tossed it on, slipped into his house shoes and grabbed his pipe from the mantle and began filling it with tobacco.


"What…” I started, just as I heard the bell ring as he dropped into this chair and lit his pipe.  I stared at him, my mouth agape.

“Well don’t just stand there, man.  Have Mrs. Hudson bring some tea.  I hope our visitor has brought us a challenge.  I do believe any more of you trying to entertain me may bring you to the brink of insanity!”

And that, dear readers, is how not to keep Sherlock busy on a sunny day in June during Queen Victoria’s Golden Jubilee.

Wednesday, May 18, 2022

May News and Announcements

It was so great to meet again in person this month!  Twelve Sherlockians gathered to discuss Wisteria Lodge with some interesting discussions on the relationship between Scott Eccles and Garcia, the impression that Inspector Baynes made on all of us, the problem with the dates in this story, the inconsistencies with the governess's story, and the racism running through the whole tale.  But if you want to be a part of our discussions, you'll have to join us at our next meeting in July!


Some interesting news and announcements came out of this month's meeting that we'd like to share, specifically about our conference...

Holmes in the Heartland will return in the summer of 2023!  

Details are still being worked out, but we hope you can join us in late July next year for the return of our conference.  Next year's theme will be the one that Covid put on hold: Arch Enemies.  Look for more information coming soon!

Sherlollicon will take place online June 4 & 5.

The Harpooners of the Sea Unicorn will have their monthly meeting this Friday evening on Zoom.

The Noble Bachelors of St. Louis will host their annual Sherlockian picnic at Tower Grove Park on June 5 at 11:00.

Lone Star Holmes will take place in Dallas, TX on May 26 & 27, 2023.

The Friends of the Arthur Conan Doyle Collection at the Toronto Public will host Jubilee @ 221B on September 23-25.

The Baker Street Irregulars will present Sherlock Holmes and the British Empire in Bear Mountain, NY on July 29-31.

Our next meeting will be on July 9 to discuss The Bruce-Partington Plans.  Come at once if convenient!



Thursday, March 24, 2022

March News and Announcements

This month was our last Zoom meeting for a while and we welcomed all kinds of new folks to our group.  Sherlockians from England, Canada, Egypt, France, and the Czech Republic, as well as all across America were on hand.  And there were plenty of events to announce to everyone!


The Occupants of the Empty House in Southern Illinois will meet again in person on April 2 in DuQuoin, IL.

221B Con will be on April 8-10 in Atlanta, GA.

A Celebration of Sherlock Holmes will be held at DePaul University in Chicago on May 7.

Sherlolicon will be held online June 4-5.

The BSI will host Sherlock Holmes and the British Empire in Bear Mountain, NY on July29-31.

The updated International Exhibition of Sherlock Holmes will be in St. Paul, MN in October.

Lone Star Holmes will be held in Dallas, TX on May 26-27, 2023.


And we are finally to meet back in person!  Starting in May, our bi-monthly meetings will be hosted again at The Ethical Society of St. Louis.

May 14: Wisteria Lodge

July 9: The Red Circle

September 10: The Bruce-Partington Plans

November 12: The Disappearance of Lady Frances Carfax

But to keep in touch with our out-of-town friends, we will host two Zoom meetings this year:

October 15: The Dying Detective (via Zoom)

December 10: The Devil’s Foot (via Zoom)

And for Sherlockians still looking to connect via Zoom, you can count on monthly meetings from The John H. Watson Society and Five Miles From Anywhere.

Make sure you stay up-to-date with Parallel Case of St. Louis news and events on our Facebook page and Twitter account!